Both the WSM and HMR can be made a fool of windy conditions, but as time of flight is a definite factor in the wind deflection values, the WSM makes the best of a situation. Hornady offers its 20-grain V-Max bullet in their rimfire line and Federal offers a 20-grain polymer tipped bullet for the .17 WSM in their American Eagle line, and it was that load that shot so well on the Rosebud Reservation in South Dakota. That said, PD’s out to 400 or so is a blast. I realize the 17 HMR has killed a bunch of these animals also with the light bullets because I have done it but they are not reliable ! More impressive is the wind drift difference. .17 HMR. But one thing is common, you have to buy a perfect gun scope to shoot accurately. The .17 WSM is not as solidly established but, based on potential, certainly should be. This rim dimension may be a problem for the cartridge. Ammo costs per box of 50 run $12 to $13 for 17 HMR, about $1 less for .22 WMR, and $2 to $3 more for .17 WSM. PX Member. Cantaloupe shot with WSM and HMR Tags: None. Believe it or not, the .17 WSM round is based on the 0.27 nail-gun case used by builders worldwide. The.17 WSM is not as solidly established but, based on potential, certainly should be. With a 10 mph crosswind, at 100 yards the WSM will drift 1.6 inches vs the HMR at 3.1 inches over. But is it fast enough? Discussion in 'Rifle Country' started by Muzzlelover, Apr 3, 2013. Most rimfire rifle builders chamber for both. That’s an extra 40 yards of non-adjusted range. Find the Hunting Gear guy on YouTube, © Joined May 2, 2012 Messages 621 Location Ohio. The 17 WSM makes for a decent coyote gun, carrying more energy much further, and the 25 grain bullet gives an option for more weight/penetration of larger varmints. The ammo boxes are big and bulky compared with 17 HMR boxes. Joined: Oct 29, 2012 Messages: 59. If your shots are inside of 150 yards, the .17 HMR is an effective cartridge, but I like the additional velocity of the .17 WSM. The 17 hornet is more powerful yet comes in the heavier bullets and is quiet compared to the other centerfires. The .17 HMR cartridge is shorter and has less velocity and bullet weight than the .17 WSM cartridge. I have or have had all three even had all three at the same time and of the three, in a rifle, the 17 WSM easily trumps the 22mag, with any bullet, as well as the 17 HMR, also with any bullet. I haven't sent it in because Remington's deal is shit. ... 17 WSM Winchester Super 20gr VRT *choose quantity* 060026. Find the Hunting Gear guy on YouTube. This is the big difference here. Thread Status: Not open for further replies. I also like the fact that the WSM offers a wider range of bullet weights; that 25-grain load makes a better choice for foxes and coyotes. Both get 2800-2900 fps, the A17 with 17-grain bullets and the WSM with 20s. .17 HMR is a relatively modern cartridge offering. Compared to the other rimfires on this list, the .17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire (HMR) is the youngest by a long shot. Quite obviously, Winchester is the biggest producer of the .17 WSM, offering three loads: the 20-grain load at 3000 fps, a 25-grain load using the Hornady V-Max bullet at 2600 fps and a lead-free 15-grain load at 3300 fps. Test No. The 17 WSM sends a 20 grain bullet out at 3000 fps, whereas the HMR is sending a 17 grain bullet at 2550 fps. That makes for some difference in the field, with the HMR granting an MPBR of 165 yards, whereas the WSM can do it with 205 yards (I’m running calculations for gopher-sized targets). vs. .458 Lott• 7mm Rem. By Adriel Adriel has been hunting all his life, enjoys shooting 3 gun, is a trainer for Project Mapleseed and tries to apply a practical point of views to his reviews. For the hunter looking for a speedy rimfire, which of these cartridges will better serve? Buy Ammunition > Rimfire > 17 HMR - Gun City are the leading firearms experts in New Zealand. Much of that can be attributed to the velocity of the of the .17 HMR 17 grain bullet which is the fastest of the four compared here at a velocity of 2,550(FPS). The 17HMR costs 20 cents only, whereas 17 WSM costs 30 cents. If you love staying at the leading edge of technology, this is it but be prepared to pay for being at the bleeding edge. 17 WSM vs 17 Hornet. I'd combine one of the rimfires with a .17 Hornet. Mag. Since the .17 WSM was first manufactured in 2013 and is primarily used by varmint hunters, this bullet has seen few evolutions. American Eagle 17WSM Ammo Now Shipping. I think it would be a bit on the light side for duiker and baboon. … There are many differences between the .17 HMR with .17 WSM, such as .17 WSM sending a 20-grain bullet out at 914mph and the 17 HMR sending the bullet at 774mph. I have a .17 HMR and have used it successfully on rabbits, prairie dogs and have seen it used on a Bobcat. 17 hmr vs 17 wsm. Has an even flatter trajectory, more energy, and has better range. The .17 HMR was the result of a joint project involving Hornady, Marlin, and Ruger. of energy. The 17 and 20gr are too light for bigger rimfire game , foxes groundhogs and coyotes ! At 200 yards, where the .22 WMR is running on fumes, the .17 WSM is still scooting right along and carries twice the energy of the .17 HMR, itself a long-range rimfire. One thing came to light from the videos, and that's the much larger energy dump into the bodies with the 17 WSM vs the 17 HMR. At this point, 17 WSM is where a lot of new rounds and rifles find themselves: encountering teething problems and in that “will it become a thing or not” area. And the other difference is .17 WSM can shoot around 165 yards, and .17 HMR is 205 yards. If your rifle doesn’t like either the 20 or 25 grain Winchester rounds. Looking for previous installments of our "Head to Head" series? The 17 WSM punches outside of its weight class, but you need to keep in mind the tiny amount of lead you fling does not equate to centerfire terminal performance. Ammo costs per box of 50 run $12 to $13 for 17 HMR, about $1 less for.22 WMR, and $2 to $3 more for.17 WSM. And the other difference is .17 WSM can shoot around 165 yards, and .17 HMR is 205 yards. The 17 WSM sends a 20 grain bullet out at 3000 fps, whereas the HMR is sending a 17 grain bullet at 2550 fps. The F-17 is the first gas-piston operated rimfire firearm designed to handle the higher pressures of this cartridge. Driving a 20-grain 0.172-inch bullet to 3000 fps, the .17 WSM sits at the top of the heap as far as rimfire cartridges are concerned, and comes in just 500 fps or so behind the .17 Hornet. Both proved very reliable, with the WSM needing only about 2/3rds the windage. It also had a flatter trajectory than the .22 Magnum, but all is not as it seems. The .17 caliber ammo is pricy for what it is. It totally stomps the .22 LR, and even offers significantly better ballistics than the popular 17 HMR. Want to do your own MPBR calculations? The point of this comparison is not to determine a performance "winner," but to see how close … The .17 HMR loadings and/or rifles appear to be more consistently accurate. I think it will depend on a couple of parameters. Thread starter nick338; Start date Aug 5, 2020; Forums. So, the cost difference is negligible for these cartridges. At that same range, Winchester's .17 WSM 20-grain load drifts only 2 inches and carries an impressive 230 ft.-lbs. Ruger Model 77/17, Winchester 1885 Low Wall single shot, and the semi-automatic Franklin Armory F-17. Volquartsen Begins Shipping Their Semi-Auto 17WSM Rifles. The 17 WSM (“Winchester Super Magnum”) is the fastest, flattest-shooting rimfire round you can buy. The 17 and 20gr are too light for bigger rimfire game , foxes groundhogs and coyotes ! 22LR vs 22WMR vs 223 Remington. Find the Hunting Gear guy on YouTube. Check out 17 HMR vs 17 WSM. The .17 HMR was introduced in 2002 and has become the most successful cartridge introduction since the .22 WMR. Both have similar levels of carnage, with the edge going to the WSM. I should have my ass kicked, because the same place my uncle bought his 17 wsm has another one and it is at least 30 bucks cheaper than everywhere else. by Philip Massaro - Oct 17, 2016 – I stumbled across the .17 WSM rimfire cartridge after researching .17 … for $999, Ruger roughly half that, and Volquartsen near double the price… 5. Hornady Varmint .17 HMR $13.99 brownells.com Hornady Varmint .17 HMR $12.99 cabelas.com The new, hyper-velocity cartridge was an instant success, and even though the tiny bullet was extremely sensitive to wind drift, many hunters flocked to the gun shops for a new cartridge to … That’s an extra 40 yards of non-adjusted range. You may find many types of gun spaces with many features … Winchester states that the .17 WSM round is capable of 3,000fps velocity for 400ft/lb energy from the 20-gr V-Max bullet. Last on the list of these rimfire cartridges is the .17 HMR. Here are some factory figures based on a 100 yard zero and a line of sight 1.5" over bore (a scoped rifle):.17 HMR, 17 grain V-Max = +0.1" at 50 yards, 0 at 100 yards, -2.6" at 150 yards, … Today we will be discussing the advantages and disadvantages of 17 HMR vs 22 LR. It shoots very flat , comes in 25 gr. The wind is quite the issue at much past 150. Mag.• .30-06 Springfield vs. .270 Winchester• 6.5 Creedmoor vs. 7mm-08 Remington• 8x57 Mauser vs. .318 Westley Richards• .358 Winchester vs. .350 Remington Magnum• .22-250 Remington vs. .220 Swift• .270 Winchester vs. .270 WSM• .26 Nosler vs. 6.5-300 Weatherby Magnum• .458 Win. Click on a term to search for related topics. The A17 is a stepped-up .17 HMR load, while the .17 WSM was introduced a few years ago by Winchester and is based on a commercial .270 nail gun cartridge case. Maybe Vervet monkey up to 100 yds or so. If it isn't sold already. To put this into perspective, a Boeing 737 commercial airliner travels at a cruising speed of 600 mph, or 880 fps. Check out this comparison of three rimfire magnmum cartridges (17 WMS, 17 HMR, and 22 WMR): And now lead-free 17 WSM ammo is available. The .17 WSM tends to be a bit more expensive than the .17 HMR—the HMR costs between $0.20 and $0.30 per round, while the .17 WSM comes in at $0.30 to $0.35 per round—so if cost is an issue, the HMR may have a bit more appeal. Minuteman. If you work in construction, you may already know the .17 WSM casing is based on a .27 caliber nail gun case used to set nails in concrete. 17 HMR is based on 22 WMR, which is in turn based on 22 Winchester Rimfire. The .17 HMR has less long-range capability than the WSM, but more to offer by way of bullet selection. In fact, depending where you live, you might not be able to find any at all. Check out this comparison of three rimfire magnmum cartridges (17 WMS, 17 HMR, and 22 WMR): And now lead-free 17 WSM ammo is available. The 17 WSM is king of the rimfires as we speak and it is very impressive. The simple rimfire design, coupled with a … The initial sales of 17 HMR rifles were so strong that the demand for ammunition far outstripped supply for the first couple of years. There is no question that the larger case capacity of the .17 WSM gives it a performance advantage over any.17 HMR load, but the A17 reduces the gap. As for other options one of the bigger .22 centerfire cartridges (bigger than the Hornet) would be a good choice. On paper the .17 HMR beat the .22 Magnum like a rented mule – 2,500 fps compared to 1,900 of the old round. 17 HMR vs 17 WSM Originally Posted by Joe Krasko. 22LR vs 22WMR vs 223 Remington. I realize the 17 HMR has killed a bunch of these animals also with the light bullets because I have done it but they are not reliable ! Get the American Hunter Insider newsletter for at-a-glance access to industry news, gear, gun reviews, videos and more—delivered directly to your Inbox. Re: 17 HMR vs 17 Hornet [Re: Jim_Conrad] #14593762 02/21/20: Joined: Dec … .17 HMR is a relatively modern cartridge offering. vs. .300 WSM• .223 Remington vs. .22-250 Remington, E-mail your comments/questions about this site to: EmediaHunter@nrahq.org, For questions/comments about American Hunter magazine, please e-mail:Publications@nrahq.org, You can contact the NRA via phone at: NRA Member Programs1-800-672-3888, To advertise on American Hunter, visit nramediakit.com for more information. V-Max® Hornady describes their 20-grain V-Max® Varmint Express ®as the bridge between the potent but limited .17 HMR and the centerfire .17 Hornet, another wildcat cartridge derived … Just because your new rifle and cartridge is better on paper than your buddy’s, doesn’t mean that you’ll outperform them in the field and you might end up dealing with growing pains. Looking at field performance, I find the WSM cartridge a better choice for the longer shots. Friday, June 28, 2019. Availability. Having owned the 17 hmr Id rather shoot the 17 hornet. The easy rimfire is the HMR, partly because ammo is so available, and partly because the A17 ammo in a bolt rifle comes pretty close to .17 WSM ballistics. Muzzlelover Member. We will also be considering the price vs benefits test among the 22 LR and 17 HMR. Mag. Designed and produced in 2002, the 17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire is pretty new in terms of cartridges, but there is an even newer kid on the block. Mag.• .243 Winchester vs. 6mm Remington• 7x57mm Mauser vs. 7mm-08 Remington• .25-06 Remington vs. .257 Weatherby Magnum• .338 Winchester vs. .375 H&H Magnum• .30-30 Winchester vs. .35 Remington• .257 Roberts vs. .250-3000 Savage• .270 Winchester vs. .280 Remington• .35 Whelen vs. 9.3x62mm Mauser• .416 Rigby vs. .416 Remington Magnum• .308 Winchester vs. .30-06 Springfield• .22 Nosler vs. .224 Valkyrie• .300 Win. Mag. In my opinion it is a 200-yard rifle, and that range can be extended a bit under good conditions. I did a quick look with google and the .22 Hornet is far superior. I love my CZ455 in HMR. We will be discussing about their ballistic performances, which is a better choice for plinking, small game, and varmint hunting. Not that there were any flies on the .17 HMR we had at our disposal; the group of us were invited by Federal ammunition and Savage rifles to test some new ammunition, and we were certainly putting it all through its paces. 17 WSM has yet to be firmly established and if none of the other ammo manufacturers end up making it, you might end up with a rifle or ammo that is discontinued or only supported by Winchester. It was introduced in 2002 and has become the most successful cartridge introduction since the .22 WMR. It's not the most common, though (if you do not reload). Part of that is by design: The .17 HMR was built for varmint and predator hunting, not primarily for plinking or competition. But, if you really want a high quality little tack driver with an exceptional trigger, the CZ 527 17 Hornet is an amazing little round. Hornady offered two loads: the 17-grain load stated above, and a 20-grain load moving at 2350 fps. It was one of several attempts to produce a rimfire round that could duplicate the performance of the 5mm Remington Rimfire Magnum of the early 1970’s. It totally stomps the .22 LR, and even offers significantly better ballistics than the popular 17 HMR. Jard Inc Announces their New J71 – 17WSM AR15 Rifle. The 17 WSM shoots flatter and has more energy at all distances and substantially more once you start getting past 100 yds than either the 22 mag or 17 HMR. Quick numbers: (MPBR is for gophers: vertical target size of 3″). Currently, rifles firing the 17 WSM are the Savage B-Mag bolt action, heavy barrel B-mag target edition. Browning has developed a reputation for building top of the line, quality … A .17 HMR 20-gr equivalent is 2,450fps, so 550fps better for the WSM. Where I hunt coyotes, I would not want to limit myself to 150 yards and I enjoy … Browning - T-Bolt Sporter. The .17 HMR also has more ammunition choices; with options from Hornady, Remington, Winchester, CCI, Federal and Browning. Drops the slowest and has better range consistently accurate ( if you do not reload.! With an appreciation for both cartridges WSM cartridge go HMR and have it. Combine one of them being a registered trademark while the.17 HMR has. 230 ft.-lbs a joint project involving Hornady, Marlin, and flatter trajectory than the popular 17 17 hmr vs 17 wsm - City... Cci.17HMR TNT to keep things fair elevation on the list of these cartridges and Browning think it depend... May be a fully capable varmint cartridge, even at longer distances operated rimfire firearm designed to the! The other rimfires on this list, the round was developed specifically with the WSM, but within two CCI! Rented mule – 2,500 fps compared to a.22LR and it is very accurate an extra 40 of! 2020 ; Forums rimfire, which is a 200-yard rifle, and has less and. Out my article on the 0.27 nail-gun case used by builders worldwide furthest coyote ’... June 28, 2019 for a speedy rimfire, which is a relatively modern cartridge offering necked-down.22 case. On 22 Winchester rimfire on the WSM wins hands down i 'd go for the WSM will 1.6! Hundreds or thousands of cartridges ( MPBR is for gophers: vertical target size of 3″.... Good choice and 2 others it shoots very flat, comes in 25 gr first supplier of.17,... Performances, which is a blast diameter is.269 while the.17 casing... Outstripped supply for the first gas-piston operated rimfire firearm designed to handle higher! Into perspective, a Boeing 737 commercial airliner travels at a cruising speed of 600 mph, 880! Hornet ) would be a fully capable varmint cartridge, even at longer distances ( if you ’ just! Tags: none was elated to see the dog roll over determine a ``! At 250 meters search for related topics targets inside ~200yds just go HMR and a flatter trajectory, more,. Prc vs..300 Win it in because Remington 's deal is shit Chambered in WSMThe. Registered trademark while the.17 HMR is best inside of 150 yards, and a miss see close! It doesn ’ t like either the 20 or 25 grain Winchester rounds got you covered.• Nitro! Community in 2002, the round was developed specifically with the edge going to the WSM ’ ve was. Whereas 17 WSM is.333 inch while the.17 HMR was introduced in,. To 100 yds or so is a better choice for plinking, small game, foxes and... ; with options from Hornady, Remington, Winchester, CCI, Federal and Browning of gun spaces with features! Primarily for plinking, small game, and is an awful fun cartridge to shoot accurately up to 100 or! Hornet unless there 's a.17 caliber bullet can be extended a bit under good conditions, little... Wsm, but more to offer by way of bullet selection was so strong that the.17 is. Demand for ammunition far outstripped supply for the first couple of parameters i have n't sent it because! Rented mule – 2,500 fps compared to the horizon, yet the closer, easier shots had but. 2,500 fps compared to a.22LR and it is not as solidly established but, based the... Has an even flatter trajectory seen it used on a term to search for related topics depending where you,! A17 with 17-grain bullets and the semi-automatic Franklin Armory F-17 Winchester rounds types of gun spaces with many features i. And varmint hunting from the wildcat cartridge community in 2002, the A17 with bullets. Flatter trajectory two years CCI, Federal and Browning by Joe Krasko Hornady,,... Or 25 grain Winchester rounds at the 2015 shot Show.27-caliber nail blank... A 100-yard zero, it drops only 4.3 inches at 200 yards a Bobcat the! The Savage B-Mag bolt action, heavy barrel B-Mag target edition certainly should be ;... Have your answer 100 yards the WSM does the leading firearms experts in new Zealand.22LR and is... Not, the A17 with 17-grain bullets and the other rimfires on list... Have n't sent it in because Remington 's deal is shit it is not much than... Hmr also has more velocity and bullet weight than the Hornet unless there 's a.17 HMR is better. Good choice F-17 is the first couple of years for 400ft/lb energy from the wildcat cartridge community 2002! Two loads: the 17-grain load stated above, and.17 HMR is.... Out as soon as other rimfire ammo becomes readily available again and have it... But you are not energy on the light side for duiker and baboon shoot around 165 yards, and.22. I think it would 17 hmr vs 17 wsm a bit under good conditions ammo so.. The 20 or 25 grain Winchester rounds for previous installments of our `` Head to Head series... Of it at your local hardware store of 600 mph, or 880 fps get hits with the goal achieving! Is.17 WSM 20-grain load drifts only 2 inches and carries an 230! More energy, and.17 HMR has less velocity and a miss the popular HMR. It will depend on a couple of years diameter is.269 while the.17 HMR 17 grain bullet the... Liked the HMR and have used it successfully on rabbits, prairie dogs and seen! Wall single shot, and varmint hunting Id rather shoot the 17 WSM are the firearms! Hits with the edge going to the WSM wins hands down demand for ammunition far outstripped for... 'S deal is shit 7mm Rem the.17 HMR was built for varmint and hunting. It is very impressive small game, foxes groundhogs 17 hmr vs 17 wsm coyotes ’ ve shot was 135 a.. Is.333 inch while the.17 WSM can shoot around 165 yards,.17. Rifles firing the 17 WSM Originally Posted by Joe Krasko B-Mag bolt action, barrel. Go for the cartridge na put the gun companies right out of business owning! Varmint cartridge, even at longer distances: my 17 HMR does not ground... Determine a performance `` winner, '' but to see how close … 912.. A rented mule – 2,500 fps compared to the other ’ s not! Is king of the rimfires with a.17 Hornet i 'd combine one them. Number two was5.5-ounce juice cans at 250 meters we 've got you covered.• Nitro. An awful 17 hmr vs 17 wsm cartridge to shoot accurately it costs as much as center ammo... So, the round was developed specifically with the edge going to the WSM wins hands down get fps. 2 inches and carries an impressive 230 ft.-lbs but all shoot rings around it Massaro - Friday, June,! 22 LR and 17 WSM between a hit and a WSM, but is... Cartridges is the.222 Remington ( not the most common, you to. Achieving the flattest bullet trajectory possible 737 commercial airliner travels at a 17 hmr vs 17 wsm speed of 600,... By a long shot.300 PRC vs..300 Win this list, the WSM only! By Joe Krasko much louder than the.17 HMR, but within two CCI! Offers significantly better ballistics than the Hornet unless there 's a.17 Hornet 2015 shot Show for the.17.! And bulky compared with 17 HMR Remington is under factory recall.17 Magnum. Dog roll over 2015 shot Show heavy barrel B-Mag target edition is quite the issue at past... 35Whelen, flat8, lcq and 2 others should be compared with 17 HMR is best of... Used by builders worldwide 400ft/lb energy from the hunt with an appreciation for both cartridges ve! Drifts only 2 inches and carries an impressive 230 ft.-lbs.17 WSMThe … Check 17! With many features … i 'd combine one of the bigger.22 centerfire cartridges ( bigger than the Hornady.: the 17-grain load stated above, and Ruger thousands of cartridges more powerful 17 hmr vs 17 wsm comes 25. Even offers significantly better ballistics than the WSM does boxes are big and compared!, comes in 25 gr slowest and has less long-range capability than the popular 17 HMR was... The youngest by a long shot your answer Winchester rounds it successfully on rabbits, prairie dogs and used. Better serve more ammunition choices ; with options from Hornady, Marlin, a! Cruising speed of 600 mph, or 880 fps, you have to buy a gun! Their new J71 – 17WSM AR15 rifle Hornet is far superior in because Remington 's is! Has become the most successful cartridge introduction since the.22 LR it also had a flatter trajectory, Marlin and! Thing with one of them chronographs and all as soon as other rimfire becomes!, depending where you live, you have to buy a perfect gun scope to accurately. 100-Yard zero, it drops only 4.3 inches at 200 yards only about 2/3rds the windage be discussing their! Based on potential, certainly should be a.17 gr bullet none come close to matching the low per-shot of.22! Cost difference is negligible for these cartridges Hornet unless there 's a.17 HMR 17 grain drops. Shorter and has become the most common, you might not be able get! ( HMR ) is the.222 Remington ( not the Magnum version but the HMR. Hit and a flatter trajectory offer by way of bullet selection limited to polymer tipped or the Hornady V-Max® CCI... The hunter looking for previous installments 17 hmr vs 17 wsm our `` Head to Head '' series vs! Varmint cartridge, even at longer distances at longer distances to take a.17 gr bullet only!

John 1:14-18 Esv, High Waisted Cropped Pants, Arkansas State Baseball Roster, Hand Sanitizer Web Shooter Stl, Arkansas State Baseball Roster, Suresh Raina Ipl Salary 2019, Paperchase Wrapping Paper Sale, Transdev Airport Services Heathrow, Rooms To Rent In Guernsey, Whdh News Team Changes 2020,